Impressions de Brian, Sandra, etc sur All-Star (survivorfever)

[Pacm]

Vous avez peut-etre deja lu cet article sinon allez à http://www.survivorfever.net/s8_alumni_interview.html, ça vaut la peine de le lire et plus on lit plus on voudrait que Brian et Sandra fasse pas parti de ASS.

un petit extrait :

Citation :2- Do you feel that the season of Survivor in which you appeared was adequately represented by contestants in All Stars?

Brian Heidik:  I never talk about myself.  For you either praise, which is vanity, or you reproach, which is poor spirit, in both instances evincing a guilty heart in the speaker, which gives pain to the listener:  if it is to be avoided in private life, it is to be shunned even more in public office, where you speak to the crowd, and where you at once pass as a fool if you but give the semblance of it.  Hope you enjoyed Survivor Thailand, thank you...    

Carl Bilancione:  Lex I feel has been a good representation of Survivor Africa but Ethan and Big Tom no! Lex knows how to play the game and make decisions. Tom and Ethan just go with the flow. (just like Africa).

Clay Jordan:  Absolutely Not!  Season "5" Thailand was the worst adequately represented.  There were 16 contestants and I can think of 15 others that would have better represented the season.  

Frank Garrison:  Lex is doing a fine job. Tom is still riding on the wings of another player and Pretty boy is still a piece of furniture, eye-candy role, and GONE!

Jeff Varner:  Oh yeah…..I think the Outback season is "over" represented in this show.  There were five people from my season and that’s too many.  We did earn the highest ratings of any Survivor and the popularity with the overall S2 cast was high in comparison to other shows.  So I don’t think it’s surprising to see S2 so well represented.  But five out of 18 is too many from our show.

Kelly Wigelsworth:  It seems like they have more people from my show than the others...no I don't think my show was adequately represented because I am not there

Lindsey Richter Voreis:  YES!  Big Tom deserved another shot because he's Big Tom and he's cool.  Lex got a little screwed his first go-around, so he deserved another shot and I love him and want him to win! Ethan is adorable. You can't get away from him. He's loveable, yet aggressive, yet a vulnerable at times. He's great. I like Ethan!  

Sandra Diaz-Twine:  Yes, I'm glad Rupert was selected, I did get a call to see if I was interested in perhaps going back but I was sick and felt it was too soon, and after watching the 1st two episodes I know I made the right decision.

Tammy Leitner:  Both Boston Rob and Kathy were great TV on Marquesas. I would have liked to see Sean out there, not only to add some more diversity to the cast, but because he's so damned funny. And Paschal deserved another shot after the purple rock fiasco.


Citation :3- When you first learned which cast members were chosen, what was your reaction?  Any surprises about who was there and who wasn't included?  What other contestants would you like to have seen on All Stars?


Brian Heidik: Never the cheap rival.  Every effort to outshine an opponent lowers the standing, for competition resorts at once to mudslinging, in order to attack.  There are few who carry on war in fair fashion, for rivalry lays bare the flaws which courtesy has covered over:  many lived in honor, as long as they had no emulators.  

Carl Bilancione:  I was shocked that I was not asked (         ). Boston Rob, give me a break ( ). As far as bringing in SOME winners it did not sit right with me. Mark Burnett, the creative genius that he is, stacked one tribe and doomed the other two. One tribe not to have a winner gives it an advantage because they can concentrate on the game. The other two tribes always have in the back of their minds that if they lose a challenge a winner is going to be voted out. Psychologically, that scenario affected the play. I was surprised that Jenna was asked because she won due to sympathy from her cast members due to her mother's illness ( ). I felt that she didn't play the game that well to warrant winning (remember she asked to be voted out). To go back and play knowing her mother's terminal illness is not something I would have done and then quitting I feel was a waste of a spot. This is not the ALLSTARS but the Lucky Stars because you were fortunate to get a second chance to be part of an AMAZING experience. Jenna, I feel was picked because she posed for Playboy and is eye candy; exactly what TV ratings want!!  Hunter would have been a better choice and/or Gretchen.  The General was also a better player that surprised me that was not picked and Clarence from my show. Also, What about SURVIVOR FRANK? I was also surprised that Shii Ann was asked; what are her strengths; her whining drives me nuts. Colleen, Elizabeth, and Kelly (Africa) would have been far more entertaining. Whew; you got me on my soap box.

Clay Jordan:  Shock!  I was surprised about who was there and who was not included.  I would like to have seen Pascal, Neleh, Mike S., Helen, and of course myself.

Frank Garrison:  I was happy for the majority of them.  Still surprised winners were chosen, YES, I know its the All-Stars, but,  they were all immediate targets.  I think the game dynamics would have been better with non-winners, those so close to the taste of one-million.  No Shii Ann, like pretty-boy, boring!  That guy who danced with an elephant, and not afraid to speak his mind, now that's who should have been there!!!

Jeff Varner:  I was shocked to see Amber’s name on the list.  I was also a bit miffed at Shii Ann, as well as previous winners.  Previous winners should have been reserved for an All-Star that was all their own.  It won’t be long before there are enough of them to do it, so to throw them in the mix (as the show has evidenced) was a bad idea.  They basically agreed to get voted off quickly when they signed up.  I think the All-Star did a disservice to them.  Sean Rector was a must-have.  Little savvy Neleh would have eaten Amber alive.  Fairplay would’ve been a great partner/enemy of Mariano---there are several people that would have made this a better show.  

Kelly Wigelsworth:  Obviously I would have like to see myself there...I don't think the winners should have been invited back...that's not really fair...honestly I was surprised about the cast...I thought there would be more exciting cast members chosen...

Lindsey Richter Voreis:  I expected most of them. I was surprised about Shii Ann. I can't elaborate on her, I just don't enjoy watching her on TV. She's probably a nice person.

Sandra Diaz-Twine:  I think its a pretty good cast overall, before I was a Rupert fan I was a Mariano fan, and they are both in All-Stars...so I'm pretty happy   .

Tammy Leitner: There really weren't any surprises. All 112 past cast members could make a case about why they should be on all-stars.
That said, I was surprised most that Michael Skupin and Brian Heidik weren't included.  And I may be in the minority, but I think all the winners should have been there. How can they not be all-stars? They won. And if you're trying to find the best of the best, you have to have the winners. So I would have liked to see all the winners out there.
I would not have objected to Sean, Robb Z, the General, Gretchen, Kelly G, Helen, Deena or Christy making the cut.


Mon opinion personnelle est pas trop surprenante: Carl est fou, j'suis surpris d'etre autant en accord avec Frank pis j'aurais payé pour voir une alliance Rob-Sandra.